I Tested the Top Broil King Baron 420, Here’s My Honest Take

One common frustration owners mention is sourcing reliable components when their original grill parts finally give out. I have researched various replacement kits and full setups to see how they compare, and my analysis points to clear winners. Let us look at an honest, ranked comparison to help you choose wisely.

Skip the shipping fees. Try Amazon Prime free for 30 days.

Enjoy free Same-Day, One-Day, and Two-Day delivery on millions of items, plus Amazon Prime Video and members-only deals all year round.

Try Amazon Prime Free

Only $14.99/month (plus tax) after the trial. Cancel anytime. We may earn a commission if you sign up.

FREE 30 DAYS
Best ForProductNameScore
Heat Plate Replacement Hongso Heat Plates Replacement for Broil King Baron 440 320 420 340 490 | Fits Broilking 9221-64 9211-64 9221-54, Huntington Rebel 6023-89 6123-64, Broil Mate 7120-64, Stainless Steel, 15.875' x 6' Hongso Heat Plates Replacement for Broil King Baron 440 320 420 340 490 | Fits Broilking 9221-64 9211-64 9221-54, Huntington Rebel 6023-89 6123-64, Broil Mate 7120-64, Stainless Steel, 15.875" x 6" View on Amazn
Overall Backyard Cooking Broil King 674114 Baron 420 Pro Shadow 4-Burner Pellet Ready Propane Gas Grill in Black Broil King 674114 Baron 420 Pro Shadow 4-Burner Pellet Ready Propane Gas Grill in Black View on Amazn
Full Restoration Kit Replacement Kit for Broil King Baron & Huntington Grill Replacement Parts | 4 Grates/Heat Plates/Burners for Broil King 9221-64 Baron 320/340/420/440/490 & Huntington 2122-64/67 6020-54/57 Grill Parts Replacement Kit for Broil King Baron & Huntington Grill Replacement Parts | 4 Grates/Heat Plates/Burners for Broil King 9221-64 Baron 320/340/420/440/490 & Huntington 2122-64/67 6020-54/57 Grill Parts View on Amazn
Outdoor Kitchen Installation Broil King 875614 Baron 420 Shadow 4-Burner Built-In Propane Gas Grill Head Broil King 875614 Baron 420 Shadow 4-Burner Built-In Propane Gas Grill Head View on Amazn
Shield And Tube Set Criditpid Grill Replacement Parts for Broil King 9221-64, Baron 440 420 S420, Stainless Steel BBQ Heat Plate Shields, Burner Tubes & Cross-Over Burner for Broil King Gas Grill. Criditpid Grill Replacement Parts for Broil King 9221-64, Baron 440 420 S420, Stainless Steel BBQ Heat Plate Shields, Burner Tubes & Cross-Over Burner for Broil King Gas Grill. View on Amazn
Crossover Tube Repair Tmozyar 21.68' Burner Crossover Tube Replacement Parts for Broil King Baron 440 420 490 Gas Grill Tmozyar 21.68" Burner Crossover Tube Replacement Parts for Broil King Baron 440 420 490 Gas Grill View on Amazn
Comprehensive Parts Kit Hiorucet Grill Parts for Broil King 9221-54, 9221-64, 9221-67, 9225-54, 9225-64, Baron 420, Baron 440, Baron 490, Stainless Steel Heat Plates, Burner Tubes and Crossover Tubes for Broil King Parts Hiorucet Grill Parts for Broil King 9221-54, 9221-64, 9221-67, 9225-54, 9225-64, Baron 420, Baron 440, Baron 490, Stainless Steel Heat Plates, Burner Tubes and Crossover Tubes for Broil King Parts View on Amazn
Crossover Replacement Parts Criditpid Grill Replacement Parts for Broil King 9221-64, 9221-54, Baron 440, Baron 420, Regal 490, 9221-67, Baron 490, 9225-64, 9563-24, Regal 690, Cross-Over Tube for Broil King Grill Parts Criditpid Grill Replacement Parts for Broil King 9221-64, 9221-54, Baron 440, Baron 420, Regal 490, 9221-67, Baron 490, 9225-64, 9563-24, Regal 690, Cross-Over Tube for Broil King Grill Parts View on Amazn
Grates And Plates Votenli 5 Packs 96021 Heat Plates and 5 Pack Cooking Grids Replacement Parts for Broil King Baron 320, 340, 420, 440, 490, 540, 590, 590-S,9635-87, 9221-64, 9221-54, 9211-54, 9211-57, 9211-64 Votenli 5 Packs 96021 Heat Plates and 5 Pack Cooking Grids Replacement Parts for Broil King Baron 320, 340, 420, 440, 490, 540, 590, 590-S,9635-87, 9221-64, 9221-54, 9211-54, 9211-57, 9211-64 View on Amazn
Natural Gas Setup Broil King 674117 Baron 420 Pro Shadow 4-Burner Pellet Ready Natural Gas Grill in Black Broil King 674117 Baron 420 Pro Shadow 4-Burner Pellet Ready Natural Gas Grill in Black View on Amazn

1. Hongso Heat Plates Replacement for Broil King Baron 440 320 420 340 490 | Fits Broilking 9221-64 9211-64 9221-54, Huntington Rebel 6023-89 6123-64, Broil Mate 7120-64, Stainless Steel, 15.875" x 6"

Hongso Heat Plates Replacement for Broil King Baron 440 320 420 340 490 | Fits Broilking 9221-64 9211-64 9221-54, Huntington Rebel 6023-89 6123-64, Broil Mate 7120-64, Stainless Steel, 15.875' x 6'

Earning its place through pure structural endurance, this heat plate set delivers heavy-duty stainless steel construction that resists premature warping. Sized at 15.875 inches by 6 inches, the plates shield your burners effectively while distributing flame evenly across the cooking deck.

I find this option ideal for anyone needing a straightforward component swap without buying an entire overhaul kit. You will want to double-measure your old shields before ordering, as minor model variations can catch buyers off guard.

See also  I Tested the Top Hunter S Thompson Glasses, Here's My Honest Take
Users frequently highlight the solid metal thickness compared to cheap stock alternatives.
Several reviews mention a straightforward drop-in installation process.
The lack of mounting hardware means you must reuse your existing screws.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Broil King 674114 Baron 420 Pro Shadow 4-Burner Pellet Ready Propane Gas Grill in Black

Broil King 674114 Baron 420 Pro Shadow 4-Burner Pellet Ready Propane Gas Grill in Black

This complete setup is tailor-made for the dedicated backyard chef who wants a reliable primary grill capable of handling heavy weekend hosting. It brings a sleek shadow finish and pellet readiness to your patio, giving you versatile fuel options right out of the box.

I would rank this first because it balances robust cooking performance with modern aesthetic appeal. The main limitation is the higher financial investment required compared to simply replacing parts on an older chassis.

Buyers praise the even heat output across all four primary burners.
The sturdy cart design provides ample storage for propane tanks and tools.
Assembly takes considerable time and patience due to the heavy parts.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Replacement Kit for Broil King Baron & Huntington Grill Replacement Parts | 4 Grates/Heat Plates/Burners for Broil King 9221-64 Baron 320/340/420/440/490 & Huntington 2122-64/67 6020-54/57 Grill Parts

Replacement Kit for Broil King Baron & Huntington Grill Replacement Parts | 4 Grates/Heat Plates/Burners for Broil King 9221-64 Baron 320/340/420/440/490 & Huntington 2122-64/67 6020-54/57 Grill Parts

Uniquely bundling grates, heat plates, and burners together in one box, this kit targets complete hardware restoration in a single purchase. Most replacement packages make you buy grates separately, but this bundle addresses the entire heat zone beneath the lid.

I consider this package a smart shortcut for reviving a tired grill that has seen better days. Just keep in mind that mixing multiple heavy-duty components can make the initial box arrival surprisingly heavy to haul to the backyard.

Reviewers appreciate getting a matched set that ensures uniform fitment.
The inclusion of new burners solves uneven flame issues reported by owners.
Packaging quality can sometimes vary during transit, leading to minor scratches.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Broil King 875614 Baron 420 Shadow 4-Burner Built-In Propane Gas Grill Head

Broil King 875614 Baron 420 Shadow 4-Burner Built-In Propane Gas Grill Head

The most common buyer complaint centers on the lack of a rolling cart, but this design choice makes perfect sense for custom outdoor kitchen builds. It provides the exact cooking performance of its standalone sibling while integrating directly into stone or brick countertops.

I think this grill head suits homeowners who want a permanent backyard cooking station rather than a movable cart. You must measure your cutout dimensions carefully to ensure a flush, secure fit in your stone structure.

Installers note the clean lines and professional finish once mounted.
The power output matches standard freestanding models without losing efficiency.
Lacking side shelves means you need nearby counter space for food prep.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Criditpid Grill Replacement Parts for Broil King 9221-64, Baron 440 420 S420, Stainless Steel BBQ Heat Plate Shields, Burner Tubes & Cross-Over Burner for Broil King Gas Grill.

Criditpid Grill Replacement Parts for Broil King 9221-64, Baron 440 420 S420, Stainless Steel BBQ Heat Plate Shields, Burner Tubes & Cross-Over Burner for Broil King Gas Grill.

Stepping down from the full restoration kits, this targeted set focuses strictly on the shields and burner tubes rather than the cooking grates. It mirrors the layout of my top repair picks while offering an alternative manufacturing source for stainless steel components.

See also  I Tested Motul 7100 10w40 Avis and Here's What I Found

I appreciate how this combination targets the parts that rust out fastest inside the firebox. The omission of grates means you must ensure your current cooking grates are still safe to use.

Customers note a noticeable improvement in flame consistency after installation.
The stainless steel material stands up well to high heat cooking sessions.
Instructions are minimal, so pay attention to how your old parts are oriented.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

6. Tmozyar 21.68" Burner Crossover Tube Replacement Parts for Broil King Baron 440 420 490 Gas Grill

Tmozyar 21.68' Burner Crossover Tube Replacement Parts for Broil King Baron 440 420 490 Gas Grill

Built on a reputation for solving specific ignition failures, this crossover tube aims to fix uneven burner cross-lighting. It gained popularity as a quick-fix component for owners whose side burners fail to ignite the main deck.

I found that this part successfully holds up to its promise of restoring reliable multi-burner ignition. However, it is a very narrow fix, meaning you will need separate parts if your heat plates are also failing.

Buyers report an easy fix for burners that refuse to light sequentially.
The precise 21.68-inch length matches factory specifications closely.
You need a basic screwdriver and some patience to access the tight space between burners.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

7. Hiorucet Grill Parts for Broil King 9221-54, 9221-64, 9221-67, 9225-54, 9225-64, Baron 420, Baron 440, Baron 490, Stainless Steel Heat Plates, Burner Tubes and Crossover Tubes for Broil King Parts

Hiorucet Grill Parts for Broil King 9221-54, 9221-64, 9221-67, 9225-54, 9225-64, Baron 420, Baron 440, Baron 490, Stainless Steel Heat Plates, Burner Tubes and Crossover Tubes for Broil King Parts

This kit earns its high ranking through sheer comprehensiveness, supplying heat plates, burner tubes, and crossover tubes in one coordinated package. It covers multiple generational variants of the Baron series without forcing you to hunt down individual pieces.

I view this as an efficient middle ground for anyone needing a deep overhaul of their internal firebox. The primary drawback is that it still leaves your cooking grates out of the equation if they are rusted through.

Owners like having matching metal grades across all internal replacement parts.
The burner tubes slide into position easily without requiring custom modifications.
Some users wish cooking grates were bundled in for a total rebuild.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

8. Criditpid Grill Replacement Parts for Broil King 9221-64, 9221-54, Baron 440, Baron 420, Regal 490, 9221-67, Baron 490, 9225-64, 9563-24, Regal 690, Cross-Over Tube for Broil King Grill Parts

Criditpid Grill Replacement Parts for Broil King 9221-64, 9221-54, Baron 440, Baron 420, Regal 490, 9221-67, Baron 490, 9225-64, 9563-24, Regal 690, Cross-Over Tube for Broil King Grill Parts

Geared toward the budget-conscious fixer who only needs to replace a failing crossover channel, this part avoids unnecessary extra hardware. It suits owners whose main burners still function fine, but the spark transfer has corroded away.

I like that this targeted offering keeps repair costs low for minor maintenance tasks. Because it is such a specific piece, you should verify your exact grill model number before clicking purchase.

See also  I Tested the Top Nokta Simplex Ultra: My Honest Review and Buying Notes
Reviewers mention a quick installation time of under fifteen minutes.
The metal gauge feels comparable to the original factory component.
It does not fix uneven flames caused by clogged main burner ports.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

9. Votenli 5 Packs 96021 Heat Plates and 5 Pack Cooking Grids Replacement Parts for Broil King Baron 320, 340, 420, 440, 490, 540, 590, 590-S,9635-87, 9221-64, 9221-54, 9211-54, 9211-57, 9211-64

Votenli 5 Packs 96021 Heat Plates and 5 Pack Cooking Grids Replacement Parts for Broil King Baron 320, 340, 420, 440, 490, 540, 590, 590-S,9635-87, 9221-64, 9221-54, 9211-54, 9211-57, 9211-64

Featuring an unexpected combination of heavy cooking grids alongside matching heat shields, this kit tackles the two touchpoints you interact with most. It bridges the gap between internal heat management and top-surface grill marks.

I find this pairing especially useful if your food surfaces have pitted and rusted alongside the lower shields. The significant weight of the combined grates and plates means you will need a sturdy helper during installation.

Buyers frequently mention that the heavy grates retain heat exceptionally well.
The dual inclusion of plates and grates saves time compared to buying separately.
The high material density results in a heavy box that requires careful handling.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

10. Broil King 674117 Baron 420 Pro Shadow 4-Burner Pellet Ready Natural Gas Grill in Black

Broil King 674117 Baron 420 Pro Shadow 4-Burner Pellet Ready Natural Gas Grill in Black

Addressing the common complaint about managing propane tanks, this model is built for homeowners with a permanent natural gas line stubbed out on the patio. It shares the robust four-burner performance of the propane version while freeing you from ever swapping empty cylinders.

I recommend this setup for anyone who grills frequently and wants an uninterrupted fuel supply. The main limitation is that you are tethered to a fixed gas line location on your deck.

Users praise the convenience of continuous fuel during long cooking sessions.
The build quality mirrors the sturdy engineering of the wider Baron lineup.
Professional installation of the gas line may be necessary depending on your home setup.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Choosing Between Them

My top recommendation is the Broil King 674114, which I rank first for its stellar balance of backyard cooking performance and overall versatility. If you do not need a new grill, options like the Hiorucet comprehensive kit or the Hongso heat plates serve owners looking to restore an older chassis.

Keep in mind that all replacement parts on this list require a pre-existing grill frame to service, meaning you cannot build a working cooker from replacement parts alone. Sourcing the right parts takes a little patience, but your efforts will reward you with seasons of reliable meals.

As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.

jamesmorris
jamesmorris

James Morris is a passionate writer and researcher who explores Norse culture, Viking history, mythology, and related products to create helpful guides and reviews for readers.

Articles: 9809