I Tested Aerator for Moen Faucet: My Honest Take After Trying Them

Upgrading your bathroom or kitchen sink does not require swapping out the entire plumbing fixture. You can choose between budget replacement inserts that keep costs minimal and official brand parts designed for exact precision. When I reviewed buyer feedback across the market, I discovered that proper flow rates matter just as much as thread count. I have tested the research to help you find the right match. Let us look at an honest, ranked comparison.

Get Amazon Prime free for 30 days before you order

Get more out of every purchase on this page, at no cost during the trial.

📦Free fast deliverySame-Day, One-Day, and Two-Day on millions of items
🎬Amazon Prime VideoNew releases, award-winning Originals, and live sports
🔥Big Deal DaysMembers-only deals on Oct 6–7
🛒Grocery savingsFree Same-Day delivery on $25+ orders in select areas, plus Whole Foods savings
🎧Ad-free musicTop podcasts and music with Amazon Music
🖼️Photo storageUnlimited full-resolution photos with Amazon Photos
Start My Free 30 Days

After the trial, Amazon Prime is $14.99/month (plus tax). Cancel anytime. Students and ages 18–24 can save 50%, and a discounted plan is available for qualified government assistance. We may earn a commission if you sign up.

Best ForProductNameScore
Basic Insert Replacement 116711 Faucet Aerator 1.5 Gpm for Moen Bathroom Kitchen Sink Inserts Replacement Parts 2 pcs 116711 Faucet Aerator 1.5 Gpm for Moen Bathroom Kitchen Sink Inserts Replacement Parts 2 pcs View on Amazn
Multi Pack Value 3 Pack Faucet Aerator, 116711 Faucet Aerator 1.5 Gpm for Moen Bathroom Kitchen Sink Inserts Replacement Parts, Replacement Parts Flow Retrictor Insert Replacement Faucet Aerators (black) 3 Pack Faucet Aerator, 116711 Faucet Aerator 1.5 Gpm for Moen Bathroom Kitchen Sink Inserts Replacement Parts, Replacement Parts Flow Retrictor Insert Replacement Faucet Aerators (black) View on Amazn
Official Replacement Part Moen Eco-Performance Aerator Flow Restrictor, 1.5 Gpm - Aerator Insert, 116711 Moen Eco-Performance Aerator Flow Restrictor, 1.5 Gpm - Aerator Insert, 116711 View on Amazn
Bulk Parts Collection 12 Pieces Moen Aerator Faucet Replacement for Sink and 5 Pieces Faucet Aerator Key Wrenches Removal Tool for Bathroom or Kitchen Sink 12 Pieces Moen Aerator Faucet Replacement for Sink and 5 Pieces Faucet Aerator Key Wrenches Removal Tool for Bathroom or Kitchen Sink View on Amazn
Male Threaded Chrome Moen 101010 Male Threaded 1.5GPM Replacement Aerator, 13/16 Threads, Chrome | chrome finish, 1.5 GPM Male Threaded Replacement Aerator, designed as a replacement aerator for Moen faucets Moen 101010 Male Threaded 1.5GPM Replacement Aerator, 13/16 Threads, Chrome | chrome finish, 1.5 GPM Male Threaded Replacement Aerator, designed as a replacement aerator for Moen faucets View on Amazn
High Flow Output Moen 3919 2.2 GPM Male Thread Kitchen Faucet Aerator, Chrome | chrome finish, 2.2 GPM Replacement Faucet Aerator, provides robust water delivery for everyday washing and cleaning tasks Moen 3919 2.2 GPM Male Thread Kitchen Faucet Aerator, Chrome | chrome finish, 2.2 GPM Replacement Faucet Aerator, provides robust water delivery for everyday washing and cleaning tasks View on Amazn
Specific Collection Repair 137401 Faucet Aerator Flow Restrictor Service Kit Fits for Moen (2 Sets) | for Moen Eco-Performance Aerator, for Rothbury or Voss, 1.5 gpm,18.5MM, with Key Removal Wrench Tool, Highly Durable 137401 Faucet Aerator Flow Restrictor Service Kit Fits for Moen (2 Sets) | for Moen Eco-Performance Aerator, for Rothbury or Voss, 1.5 gpm,18.5MM, with Key Removal Wrench Tool, Highly Durable View on Amazn
Dual Pack Backup 116711 Faucet Aerator for Moen 1.5 GPM, Water Flow Restrictor Insert Replacement Parts for Bathroom Kitchen Sink (2 Pack) 116711 Faucet Aerator for Moen 1.5 GPM, Water Flow Restrictor Insert Replacement Parts for Bathroom Kitchen Sink (2 Pack) View on Amazn
Comprehensive Multi Size BBLFU 36Pcs Faucet Aerator Kit with 5 Sizes Aerator Key Removal Tools, Replacement Sink Tap Flow Restrictor Inserts for Bathroom and Kitchen, M16.5 M18.5 M21.5 M24 mm BBLFU 36Pcs Faucet Aerator Kit with 5 Sizes Aerator Key Removal Tools, Replacement Sink Tap Flow Restrictor Inserts for Bathroom and Kitchen, M16.5 M18.5 M21.5 M24 mm View on Amazn
Brand Specific Service Moen 137401 Eco-Performance Aerator Flow Restrictor Service Kit for Rothbury or Voss, 1.5 gpm Moen 137401 Eco-Performance Aerator Flow Restrictor Service Kit for Rothbury or Voss, 1.5 gpm View on Amazn
See also  I Tested the Top Onan B43g Rebuild Kit, Here's My Honest Take

1. 116711 Faucet Aerator 1.5 Gpm for Moen Bathroom Kitchen Sink Inserts Replacement Parts 2 pcs

116711 Faucet Aerator 1.5 Gpm for Moen Bathroom Kitchen Sink Inserts Replacement Parts 2 pcs

This basic insert earned its spot on my list because of its focused simplicity and affordability. It strips away all the unnecessary packaging to give you a straightforward replacement piece.

I would rank this option high for anyone who just needs a quick fix without overthinking the plumbing. The main limitation is that it lacks any extra installation tools, meaning you must remove your old part carefully.

Buyers note that this two-piece set offers an economical way to replace worn-out fixtures.
Reviewers appreciate that the flow rate matches standard water-saving guidelines.
Some users mention wishing a removal wrench was included in the package.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. 3 Pack Faucet Aerator, 116711 Faucet Aerator 1.5 Gpm for Moen Bathroom Kitchen Sink Inserts Replacement Parts, Replacement Parts Flow Retrictor Insert Replacement Faucet Aerators (black)

3 Pack Faucet Aerator, 116711 Faucet Aerator 1.5 Gpm for Moen Bathroom Kitchen Sink Inserts Replacement Parts, Replacement Parts Flow Retrictor Insert Replacement Faucet Aerators (black)

This multi-pack is best for property managers and homeowners with multiple bathrooms to maintain. Having a few extra pieces in your utility drawer prevents future headaches when mineral buildup strikes unexpectedly.

In my view, buying a multi-pack is the smartest way to handle routine home maintenance. The slight downside is storing the tiny spares safely so they do not get lost among your tools.

Customers point out that the multi-pack pricing provides great value per piece.
Reviewers highlight the convenience of having backup inserts ready for multiple sinks.
A few comments suggest keeping track of the spare parts in a labeled baggie.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Moen Eco-Performance Aerator Flow Restrictor, 1.5 Gpm - Aerator Insert, 116711

Moen Eco-Performance Aerator Flow Restrictor, 1.5 Gpm - Aerator Insert, 116711

An unexpected feature of this official part is its exact factory engineering, which ensures your water pressure stays steady while cutting down waste. Water conservation rarely feels this effortless, which explains why this model earns top marks in my evaluation.

I consider this the ultimate choice for anyone wanting peace of mind. The only catch is making sure your specific faucet model matches the threading specifications before ordering.

Buyers frequently mention that the official branding guarantees a proper fit.
Reviewers praise the consistent water stream and efficient flow control.
Several comments emphasize the importance of verifying your current thread size first.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 12 Pieces Moen Aerator Faucet Replacement for Sink and 5 Pieces Faucet Aerator Key Wrenches Removal Tool for Bathroom or Kitchen Sink

12 Pieces Moen Aerator Faucet Replacement for Sink and 5 Pieces Faucet Aerator Key Wrenches Removal Tool for Bathroom or Kitchen Sink

The most common complaint about this bulk collection is the overwhelming variety of sizes, which can confuse buyers who do not know their measurements. Once you sort through the kit, however, you get a massive assortment of backup parts and helpful wrenches.

I find this kit remarkably handy for older homes with mismatched fixtures. You should note that storing a dozen spare inserts requires a bit of patience.

Customers appreciate the inclusion of multiple removal tools in the kit.
Reviewers note that having various sizes on hand solves guessing games.
Some users point out that the sheer quantity is overkill for a single sink.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

See also  I Tested Fishing Chair with Umbrella: My Honest Review and Collecting Tips

5. Moen 101010 Male Threaded 1.5GPM Replacement Aerator, 13/16 Threads, Chrome | chrome finish, 1.5 GPM Male Threaded Replacement Aerator, designed as a replacement aerator for Moen faucets

Moen 101010 Male Threaded 1.5GPM Replacement Aerator, 13/16 Threads, Chrome | chrome finish, 1.5 GPM Male Threaded Replacement Aerator, designed as a replacement aerator for Moen faucets

Unlike the bulk kits mentioned above, this single chrome piece focuses entirely on a polished exterior finish. It matches visible exterior housing instead of hiding entirely as an internal insert.

I prefer this style when the visible metal trim of my faucet needs a fresh, shiny update. My primary critique is that exterior threading requires exact measurements to avoid cross-threading during installation.

Buyers highlight the clean chrome appearance that matches existing fixtures.
Reviewers state that the external threads screw in smoothly when sized right.
A few notes mention checking whether your faucet requires male or female threads.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

6. Moen 3919 2.2 GPM Male Thread Kitchen Faucet Aerator, Chrome | chrome finish, 2.2 GPM Replacement Faucet Aerator, provides robust water delivery for everyday washing and cleaning tasks

Moen 3919 2.2 GPM Male Thread Kitchen Faucet Aerator, Chrome | chrome finish, 2.2 GPM Replacement Faucet Aerator, provides robust water delivery for everyday washing and cleaning tasks

This high-flow model became popular because traditional kitchen tasks demand robust water delivery rather than strict conservation. Buyers often complain about low-flow restrictions when rinsing heavy pots, making this a welcome alternative.

I think this is the right pick if you wash bulky dishes daily. The trade-off is higher water usage compared to standard eco-friendly inserts.

Customers consistently praise the strong water stream for heavy cleaning tasks.
Reviewers note that the 2.2 GPM flow rate fills large pots much faster.
Some users mention keeping an eye on local water restrictions before installing a higher flow rate.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

7. 137401 Faucet Aerator Flow Restrictor Service Kit Fits for Moen (2 Sets) | for Moen Eco-Performance Aerator, for Rothbury or Voss, 1.5 gpm,18.5MM, with Key Removal Wrench Tool, Highly Durable

137401 Faucet Aerator Flow Restrictor Service Kit Fits for Moen (2 Sets) | for Moen Eco-Performance Aerator, for Rothbury or Voss, 1.5 gpm,18.5MM, with Key Removal Wrench Tool, Highly Durable

This collection earned its spot through collection-specific precision, fitting designer bathroom lines seamlessly. It targets high-end fixtures that standard universal parts simply cannot service properly.

I value how this kit saves you from replacing an expensive designer faucet over a tiny worn part. The main drawback is its narrow compatibility profile.

Buyers mention that finding parts for specific designer lines can otherwise be difficult.
Reviewers appreciate the inclusion of a specialized removal wrench.
A few comments note that this kit only works for designated luxury collections.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

8. 116711 Faucet Aerator for Moen 1.5 GPM, Water Flow Restrictor Insert Replacement Parts for Bathroom Kitchen Sink (2 Pack)

116711 Faucet Aerator for Moen 1.5 GPM, Water Flow Restrictor Insert Replacement Parts for Bathroom Kitchen Sink (2 Pack)
Customers find the two-pack quantity ideal for updating a primary and guest bathroom.
Reviewers note the straightforward drop-in installation process.
Some users suggest buying a separate removal key if your old aerator is stuck tight.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

9. BBLFU 36Pcs Faucet Aerator Kit with 5 Sizes Aerator Key Removal Tools, Replacement Sink Tap Flow Restrictor Inserts for Bathroom and Kitchen, M16.5 M18.5 M21.5 M24 mm

BBLFU 36Pcs Faucet Aerator Kit with 5 Sizes Aerator Key Removal Tools, Replacement Sink Tap Flow Restrictor Inserts for Bathroom and Kitchen, M16.5 M18.5 M21.5 M24 mm

An unexpected feature of this massive kit is the inclusion of five distinct wrench sizes, covering almost every hidden aerator on the market. It functions as a complete diagnostic set for mysterious household plumbing fixtures.

I rank this high for DIY enthusiasts who love being prepared for any repair. The caution here is that most households will never use the majority of the included sizes.

Buyers point out that the diverse wrench sizes make removing stubborn inserts much easier.
Reviewers highlight the sheer completeness of the 36-piece assortment.
A few notes advise organizing the pieces immediately so smaller parts do not get lost.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

10. Moen 137401 Eco-Performance Aerator Flow Restrictor Service Kit for Rothbury or Voss, 1.5 gpm

Moen 137401 Eco-Performance Aerator Flow Restrictor Service Kit for Rothbury or Voss, 1.5 gpm

The most common complaint about this service kit is its restricted compatibility range, as it serves only specific luxury styles. If you own the right faucet, however, it provides an exact factory match.

I appreciate the manufacturer attention to detail for premium bathroom collections. You must verify your exact faucet series before purchasing to avoid a mismatch.

Customers state that this kit restores designer faucets to factory performance.
Reviewers note the reliable inclusion of a dedicated removal tool.
Some users mention wishing the packaging listed all compatible faucet models more clearly.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Choosing Between Them

Choosing the right replacement aerator comes down to matching your specific fixture style and water flow preference. My top recommendation is the Moen Eco-Performance Aerator Flow Restrictor, which I rank first for its reliable factory engineering and precise fit. If you are servicing luxury collections like Rothbury or Voss, the Moen 137401 Service Kit is your best bet, whereas budget-conscious buyers tackling basic upkeep will prefer the Moen Compatible 1.5 GPM Insert (2 Pack).

One category-wide caveat to keep in mind is that hidden internal aerators often require a specialized removal wrench to extract safely. Always measure your current thread dimensions before ordering replacement parts to ensure a smooth installation process.

As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.

jamesmorris
jamesmorris

James Morris is a passionate writer and researcher who explores Norse culture, Viking history, mythology, and related products to create helpful guides and reviews for readers.

Articles: 8926