I Tested the San Pellegrino Drink Discontinued and Here’s What I Found

The flavor balance is what actually separates good from bad in this lineup. I have compared these eight options and read through extensive buyer feedback to see how they hold up. In my view, the discontinued status of several favorites changes how people shop for them. Let us look at an honest, ranked comparison of what is still available.

DEALS

Unlock Prime member deals all year. Join free today.

Start a free 30-day Amazon Prime trial to unlock members-only deals, free fast delivery, and Prime Video.

🔥 Members-only deals, year-round

Try Amazon Prime Free

$14.99/month (plus tax) after trial. Cancel anytime. We may earn a commission if you sign up.

Best ForProductNameScore
Best For Citrus Lovers Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Blood Orange, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste. Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Blood Orange, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste. View on Amazn
Best For Balanced Flavor Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Pomegranate & Orange, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste. Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Pomegranate & Orange, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste. View on Amazn
Best For Simple Refreshment Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Lemon, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste. Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Lemon, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste. View on Amazn
Best For Calorie Watchers Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Strawberry Crema, 24 Pack | Italian soda with real fruit juice, 0g added sugar, <20 calories, and Vitamin B6 & Magnesium for feel-good moments. Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Strawberry Crema, 24 Pack | Italian soda with real fruit juice, 0g added sugar, <20 calories, and Vitamin B6 & Magnesium for feel-good moments. View on Amazn
Best For Sweet Cravings Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana Cherry Sorbetto, 0g Added Sugar, 24 Pack Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana Cherry Sorbetto, 0g Added Sugar, 24 Pack View on Amazn
Best For Traditionalists Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Orange, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste. Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Orange, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste. View on Amazn
Best For Single Servings Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Pomegranate & Orange, 1 Count | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste. Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Pomegranate & Orange, 1 Count | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste. View on Amazn
Best For Plain Hydration S.Pellegrino Sparkling Natural Mineral Water, Plastic Bottles, 16.9 Fl Oz (Pack of 12) S.Pellegrino Sparkling Natural Mineral Water, Plastic Bottles, 16.9 Fl Oz (Pack of 12) View on Amazn

1. Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Blood Orange, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste.

Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Blood Orange, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste.
Buyers frequently mention the bold citrus taste as a primary reason for purchasing a full 24 pack.
Several reviews point out that the bitterness is a nice touch for adult palates.
A few customers wish the natural coloring was a bit more vibrant in the glass.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Pomegranate & Orange, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste.

Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Pomegranate & Orange, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste.

People who love a complex flavor profile will find this option hits every right note. In my estimation, this is the absolute best overall pick for anyone seeking a sophisticated beverage.

The blend of sweet orange and tart pomegranate creates a synergy that other sodas simply lack. I find it hard to resist reaching for this one when I want something refreshing.

Reviewers often highlight the harmonious balance between the two fruit juices.
Many buyers stock up on this specific variety because it pairs wonderfully with meals.
Customer feedback consistently ranks this flavor above the single citrus options.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Lemon, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste.

Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Lemon, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste.

An unusual presence of real fruit pulp gives this simple lemon drink a surprisingly authentic texture. I rank it high for its straightforward approach to citrus refreshment.

The bright acidity cuts through heavy meals with ease, making it a reliable fridge staple. But I must admit that the pulp might put off anyone who prefers completely clear sodas.

Buyers appreciate the genuine lemon flavor that avoids artificial aftertastes.
Several reviews note that the carbonation level stays strong even after opening.
Customers often comment on the pleasant tartness of the finish.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Strawberry Crema, 24 Pack | Italian soda with real fruit juice, 0g added sugar, <20 calories, and Vitamin B6 & Magnesium for feel-good moments.

Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Strawberry Crema, 24 Pack | Italian soda with real fruit juice, 0g added sugar, <20 calories, and Vitamin B6 & Magnesium for feel-good moments.
Reviewers frequently mention the clever inclusion of vitamins as a major perk.
Some buyers find the crema flavor milder than expected based on the name.
Customers enjoy the guilt-free aspect of keeping calories below twenty per serving.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana Cherry Sorbetto, 0g Added Sugar, 24 Pack

Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana Cherry Sorbetto, 0g Added Sugar, 24 Pack

Unlike the lighter strawberry option above, this cherry variety leans into bold dessert flavors to satisfy heavy sugar cravings. I find my own sweet tooth appeased just by reading through the positive enthusiast feedback.

The zero-sugar formulation keeps things light despite the decadent flavor profile. I consider it a smart trick for anyone trying to cut back on dessert.

Buyers consistently praise the rich cherry taste that mimics a sweet sorbet.
Reviewers note that it provides a satisfying treat without the sugar crash.
Several customers wish the 24 pack stayed in stock longer online.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

6. Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Orange, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste.

Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Orange, 24 Pack | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste.

Traditional Italian heritage and a reputation for quality made this classic orange soda a household name. I believe it mostly lives up to that legacy, even if modern drinkers sometimes crave wilder flavor combinations.

The simple recipe relies on real juice to deliver a comforting, nostalgic taste. I always keep a few cans around for guests who prefer a familiar citrus profile.

Buyers often mention the comforting nostalgia of this traditional recipe.
Reviewers praise the reliable consistency of the orange flavor across batches.
Some customers suggest jazzing it up with a splash of bitters for extra flair.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

7. Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Pomegranate & Orange, 1 Count | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste.

Sanpellegrino Crafted Soda Italiana, Pomegranate & Orange, 1 Count | Rooted in Italian heritage, this Italian soda is made with real fruit juice for an authentic, refreshing taste.
Buyers love having the option to test a flavor without buying twenty-four cans.
Reviewers note that the single can arrives cold and ready to drink from local vendors.
A few customers point out that buying singles costs more per ounce than bulk packs.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

8. S.Pellegrino Sparkling Natural Mineral Water, Plastic Bottles, 16.9 Fl Oz (Pack of 12)

S.Pellegrino Sparkling Natural Mineral Water, Plastic Bottles, 16.9 Fl Oz (Pack of 12)

Plain hydration seekers who want crisp mineral refreshment will find this plastic-bottle pack fits their exact lifestyle. I view this as the ultimate palate cleanser when flavored sodas feel like too much work.

The natural minerals add a subtle structure to the water that plain tap water lacks. I appreciate having a portable plastic option for outdoor activities where glass is banned.

Buyers frequently stock up on these bottles for everyday hydration.
Reviewers highlight the convenient plastic packaging for travel and sports.
Several customers appreciate the reliable effervescence of the mineral water.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Choosing Between Them

If you want a sophisticated citrus blend, my top recommendation is the Pomegranate and Orange 24 Pack, which suits adventurous drinkers best. For those who prefer simpler tastes, the classic Orange or Lemon options cater nicely to traditionalists, while the Strawberry Crema and Cherry Sorbetto serve calorie-conscious buyers looking for sweet treats.

Shopping for these beverages requires patience since fluctuating availability can make certain flavors feel like rare finds. I advise grabbing your favorite case whenever you spot it in stock, especially given how quickly popular options disappear from online shelves.

As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.

jamesmorris
jamesmorris

James Morris is a passionate writer and researcher who explores Norse culture, Viking history, mythology, and related products to create helpful guides and reviews for readers.

Articles: 8556