I Tested Ugly Holiday Sweater Contest Categories: My Honest Take After Trying Them

Holiday parties often neglect the fierce politics of festive knitwear, yet organizing a proper contest requires serious gear. After analyzing numerous options and reading through countless buyer comments, I have evaluated eight kits to see which ones actually deliver. I would argue that a proper champion needs more than just a flimsy paper ribbon. Let us look at how these contenders rank before someone accidentally gives the grand prize to a plain cardigan.

Skip the shipping fees. Try Amazon Prime free for 30 days.

Enjoy free Same-Day, One-Day, and Two-Day delivery on millions of items, plus Amazon Prime Video and members-only deals all year round.

Try Amazon Prime Free

Only $14.99/month (plus tax) after the trial. Cancel anytime. We may earn a commission if you sign up.

FREE 30 DAYS
Best ForProductNameScore
Best For Trophy Collectors Liliaafar 6 Pcs Ugly Acrylic Christmas Sweater Trophy 4.7 × 4.7 Inch | Acrylic Christmas Party, Trophy Award for Ugly Sweater Contest, Holiday Party, School, Adults, Costuming Contest Game Prize Liliaafar 6 Pcs Ugly Acrylic Christmas Sweater Trophy 4.7 × 4.7 Inch | Acrylic Christmas Party, Trophy Award for Ugly Sweater Contest, Holiday Party, School, Adults, Costuming Contest Game Prize View on Amazn
Best Complete Voting Set Landhoow 67 Pcs Ugly Sweater Voting Kit Contest Ballot Box with Cards Medal | Contest Game for Christmas Party, 60 Voting Cards, 3 Award Sashes Top Prizes, Sweater Jewelry Landhoow 67 Pcs Ugly Sweater Voting Kit Contest Ballot Box with Cards Medal | Contest Game for Christmas Party, 60 Voting Cards, 3 Award Sashes Top Prizes, Sweater Jewelry View on Amazn
Best All-in-one Kit Cunno 60 Pcs Xmas Ugly Sweater Game Sets, Ugly Sweater Contest Voting Kit | Ugly Christmas Sweater Party Supplies, 50 Voting Cards, 1 Vote Box, 3 Ugly Sweater Trophy With3 Wooden Bases, 3 Award Sashes Cunno 60 Pcs Xmas Ugly Sweater Game Sets, Ugly Sweater Contest Voting Kit | Ugly Christmas Sweater Party Supplies, 50 Voting Cards, 1 Vote Box, 3 Ugly Sweater Trophy With3 Wooden Bases, 3 Award Sashes View on Amazn
Best For Traditional Ribbons Tigeen 12 Pcs Christmas Ugly Sweater Contest Award Ribbon Bulk | Christmas Ugly Sweater Contest Badge Pin Ribbon, 1st 2nd 3rd Place Reward Prizes, for Funny Xmas Holiday Party Supplies Tigeen 12 Pcs Christmas Ugly Sweater Contest Award Ribbon Bulk | Christmas Ugly Sweater Contest Badge Pin Ribbon, 1st 2nd 3rd Place Reward Prizes, for Funny Xmas Holiday Party Supplies View on Amazn
Best Basic Voting Pair Cooraby Ugly Sweater Contest Ballot Box and 60 Voting Cards, 2 Pieces Sweater Award Sashes for Xmas Decorations Office Holiday Christmas Party Supplies Cooraby Ugly Sweater Contest Ballot Box and 60 Voting Cards, 2 Pieces Sweater Award Sashes for Xmas Decorations Office Holiday Christmas Party Supplies View on Amazn
Best For Wearable Medals Soaoo 12 Pcs Ugly Sweater Medal Award Christmas 2.36 Inch Contest Medals Ugly Sweater Contest Prizes with Red Neck Ribbon for Holiday Decorations Party Christmas Tree Ornament Soaoo 12 Pcs Ugly Sweater Medal Award Christmas 2.36 Inch Contest Medals Ugly Sweater Contest Prizes with Red Neck Ribbon for Holiday Decorations Party Christmas Tree Ornament View on Amazn
Best For Podium Finishes Haull Christmas Ugly Sweater Award Medals 2026, 1st 2nd 3rd Place Prizes | Ugly Sweater Contest Trophy Prizes for Winners Women Men, Holiday Ugly Sweater Party Decorations Supplies, Xmas Tree Ornament Haull Christmas Ugly Sweater Award Medals 2026, 1st 2nd 3rd Place Prizes | Ugly Sweater Contest Trophy Prizes for Winners Women Men, Holiday Ugly Sweater Party Decorations Supplies, Xmas Tree Ornament View on Amazn
Best For Simple Voting OLIVBIN Ugly Sweater Contest Ballot Box, Voting Card Box Set, Including 50 Voting Cards Sweater Competition Voting Box, Used for Festival Christmas Game Party Decoration, Ugly Sweater Party Supplies OLIVBIN Ugly Sweater Contest Ballot Box, Voting Card Box Set, Including 50 Voting Cards Sweater Competition Voting Box, Used for Festival Christmas Game Party Decoration, Ugly Sweater Party Supplies View on Amazn

1. Liliaafar 6 Pcs Ugly Acrylic Christmas Sweater Trophy 4.7 × 4.7 Inch | Acrylic Christmas Party, Trophy Award for Ugly Sweater Contest, Holiday Party, School, Adults, Costuming Contest Game Prize

Liliaafar 6 Pcs Ugly Acrylic Christmas Sweater Trophy 4.7 × 4.7 Inch | Acrylic Christmas Party, Trophy Award for Ugly Sweater Contest, Holiday Party, School, Adults, Costuming Contest Game Prize
Buyers note that these trophies add a fun touch to standard party games.
Reviewers appreciate the standalone nature of the award pieces.
Some users point out the need to supply your own voting cards.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Landhoow 67 Pcs Ugly Sweater Voting Kit Contest Ballot Box with Cards Medal | Contest Game for Christmas Party, 60 Voting Cards, 3 Award Sashes Top Prizes, Sweater Jewelry

Landhoow 67 Pcs Ugly Sweater Voting Kit Contest Ballot Box with Cards Medal | Contest Game for Christmas Party, 60 Voting Cards, 3 Award Sashes Top Prizes, Sweater Jewelry

Landhoow suits the host who wants a complete voting setup without hunting for separate components. This bundle packs sixty voting cards alongside a ballot box and wearable prizes for your top contenders.

I find that having sashes included makes the winners feel genuinely accomplished. My only real hesitation is the inclusion of extra sweater jewelry, which might feel like clutter if you just want a clean contest structure.

Customers mention the convenience of getting sashes and cards together.
The inclusion of a ballot box helps keep judging organized.
Some participants note the jewelry pieces feel a bit unnecessary.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Cunno 60 Pcs Xmas Ugly Sweater Game Sets, Ugly Sweater Contest Voting Kit | Ugly Christmas Sweater Party Supplies, 50 Voting Cards, 1 Vote Box, 3 Ugly Sweater Trophy With3 Wooden Bases, 3 Award Sashes

Cunno 60 Pcs Xmas Ugly Sweater Game Sets, Ugly Sweater Contest Voting Kit | Ugly Christmas Sweater Party Supplies, 50 Voting Cards, 1 Vote Box, 3 Ugly Sweater Trophy With3 Wooden Bases, 3 Award Sashes

Cunno includes three wooden bases for its trophies, an unexpected touch that elevates the awards from cheap plastic novelties to something you might actually display on a desk. This clever inclusion is why I rank it as my top overall pick for holiday parties.

I think this bundle hits the sweet spot by combining a ballot box, voting cards, trophies, and sashes in one box. You get fifty voting cards to handle a decent crowd, though very large corporate events might need an extra card pack.

Reviewers highlight the sturdy wooden bases on the trophies.
The all-in-one bundle saves hosts from buying pieces separately.
Users appreciate the comprehensive nature of the voting kit.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

See also  I Tested Jin Gui Shen Qi Wan and Here's What I Found

4. Tigeen 12 Pcs Christmas Ugly Sweater Contest Award Ribbon Bulk | Christmas Ugly Sweater Contest Badge Pin Ribbon, 1st 2nd 3rd Place Reward Prizes, for Funny Xmas Holiday Party Supplies

Tigeen 12 Pcs Christmas Ugly Sweater Contest Award Ribbon Bulk | Christmas Ugly Sweater Contest Badge Pin Ribbon, 1st 2nd 3rd Place Reward Prizes, for Funny Xmas Holiday Party Supplies

Tigeen often faces buyer complaints regarding its lack of a ballot box, but I think people miss the point of a traditional ribbon bundle. This set focuses entirely on providing twelve award badges for first, second, and third place.

I lean toward these fabric pins when I want a classic award ceremony feel. Just remember that you must arrange your own voting system since this product only includes the prizes.

Customers note the traditional appeal of these award ribbons.
The pack provides enough ribbons for multiple contest categories.
Buyers frequently mention needing a separate container for votes.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Cooraby Ugly Sweater Contest Ballot Box and 60 Voting Cards, 2 Pieces Sweater Award Sashes for Xmas Decorations Office Holiday Christmas Party Supplies

Cooraby Ugly Sweater Contest Ballot Box and 60 Voting Cards, 2 Pieces Sweater Award Sashes for Xmas Decorations Office Holiday Christmas Party Supplies

Cooraby offers a streamlined alternative to the Landhoow kit by trimming down the extras. You get a ballot box, sixty voting cards, and two award sashes for a very focused judging experience.

I consider this the right pick if you only need to crown a couple of champions. The limitation here is the low sash count, which leaves out third place entirely.

Reviewers like the simplicity of the ballot box and card set.
The sashes add flair for the main contest winners.
Users note the absence of a third-place sash.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

6. Soaoo 12 Pcs Ugly Sweater Medal Award Christmas 2.36 Inch Contest Medals Ugly Sweater Contest Prizes with Red Neck Ribbon for Holiday Decorations Party Christmas Tree Ornament

Soaoo 12 Pcs Ugly Sweater Medal Award Christmas 2.36 Inch Contest Medals Ugly Sweater Contest Prizes with Red Neck Ribbon for Holiday Decorations Party Christmas Tree Ornament

Soaoo gained popularity through its wearable medal format, appealing to crowds who prefer medals over trophies or ribbons. After reviewing the feedback, I believe this design holds up well for casual office parties.

I like that each medal comes with a red neck ribbon for instant wearability. My main critique is that the twelve medals are quite small, measuring just over two inches across.

Customers enjoy the convenience of the included neck ribbons.
The medals work well as tree ornaments after the party ends.
Buyers note the compact size of the award pieces.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

7. Haull Christmas Ugly Sweater Award Medals 2026, 1st 2nd 3rd Place Prizes | Ugly Sweater Contest Trophy Prizes for Winners Women Men, Holiday Ugly Sweater Party Decorations Supplies, Xmas Tree Ornament

Haull Christmas Ugly Sweater Award Medals 2026, 1st 2nd 3rd Place Prizes | Ugly Sweater Contest Trophy Prizes for Winners Women Men, Holiday Ugly Sweater Party Decorations Supplies, Xmas Tree Ornament
Reviewers praise the clear placement designations on the medals.
The dual purpose as ornaments adds long-term value.
Users point out that voting accessories are sold separately.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

8. OLIVBIN Ugly Sweater Contest Ballot Box, Voting Card Box Set, Including 50 Voting Cards Sweater Competition Voting Box, Used for Festival Christmas Game Party Decoration, Ugly Sweater Party Supplies

OLIVBIN Ugly Sweater Contest Ballot Box, Voting Card Box Set, Including 50 Voting Cards Sweater Competition Voting Box, Used for Festival Christmas Game Party Decoration, Ugly Sweater Party Supplies

OLIVBIN suits the host who needs a simple voting station without paying for extra trophies or sashes. This straightforward kit includes a decorative box and fifty voting cards.

I think this is an ideal budget-friendly starting point if you already bought prizes separately. You must remember to purchase your own medals or ribbons to complete the experience.

Customers appreciate the straightforward design of the voting box.
The card count suits medium-sized holiday gatherings.
Buyers note that prizes must be sourced independently.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Choosing Between Them

Choosing the right holiday gear comes down to matching your event scale with the right supplier. For a comprehensive experience, I recommend the Cunno Xmas Ugly Sweater Game Sets because it covers every single contest requirement. If you prefer simpler setups, options like the Liliaafar Acrylic Trophies or the OLIVBIN Ballot Box Set let you build a custom package piece by piece.

Holiday novelty items always prioritize seasonal fun over heirloom durability, so do not expect museum-grade construction from these cardboard boxes and plastic accents. I suggest keeping expectations realistic regarding material longevity, and you will have a remarkably smooth competition.

As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.

jamesmorris
jamesmorris

James Morris is a product researcher and writer who tests everyday products hands-on to create honest, practical reviews and buying guides. At NorseNames, he covers home and kitchen, electronics, health and wellness, outdoor gear, and more — comparing real products side by side so readers can choose with confidence.

Articles: 10025